In the above quotation from the Manu-smriti expression na hisyd is translated as "never offend" or "never injure". It is a self-imposed ban by Hindus. expressive of a blessing (to these helpless animals) were pronounced. Vedic texts contain verses that support animal sacrifice , then why does Hinduism generally consider eating non-veg to be sin? Here's Why Millions Of People Don't Eat Beef - Mashed And is eating cow meat considered holy according to it? Im a Hindu, but I had meat. Vishnu Puran 2.6.8. However, it should be noted that austerities like Chandrayana etc. i think it's JyAna rasmi? That is fine because it is a marriage. Reverence for the cow is part of our identity. sacrifices and religious rites speak highly of slaughter of animals in For the 2nd there is a lots. Sura, (all other) intoxicating drinks and decoctions and flesh are the food of the Yakshas, Rakshasas, and Pisakas.. (creation is) the food of the vital spirit. No offense to Hindu people here, but throughout history there have been (and still are) Hindu communities that eat beef, and that's not even considering the fact that there is no such thing as an objective Hinduism -- it's a complex idea that different people can define differently for their different purposes. 2. are quite cumbersome to perform. 6 . worshipping the gods or the manes, seeks to increase (the bulk of) Deutsche Bahn Sparpreis Europa ticket validity. a cow which is declared in the scriptures to be like unto one's But this forum insists on Scriptures to prove. Not everything is written in the scriptures. sacrifices.", 'Cast thy eyes, O Jajali, on those bullocks yoked to the plough. sacrificial fires and Govardhana Hill. Mahabharata, Anusasana Parva, Section LXXXVIII. by entirely avoiding (the use of) flesh. The fact that we may know someone who eats beef cannot be considered the standard by which we take ideological positions on issues. According to these texts , "the cow is food.". In the above verses we see that the Vedic sacrifice should be done for the pleasure of the Lord Krishna, cows, Govardhana Hill, and Brahmanas! Cows have been slaughtered to insult the Hindu people. There is the story of the great Chhatrapati Shivaji Maharaj who was so enraged by the slaughter of a cow that he attacked Adil Shahi soldiers as a young boy. Slay not cow, horse, or man of ours. Is non-veg not allowed in Hinduism? I didnt really say anything. Cheers! We are not supposed to kill those who we should protect! I will update more references. During the two (following) months he shall eat a small (quantity of food) without any factitious salt at every fourth Even then, the farthest the overwhelming majority of us travel is the opinion that consuming beef is a culinary choice. It is said in the Srimad Bhagavatam (Bhagavata Purana) 8.19.43 that in time of danger one should be engaged in go-brhmana-arthe "protecting cows and brahminical culture" (paraphrased). At last, Sanity has arrived. In Indian religions Legislation against the slaughter of cattle is in place throughout most states of India except Kerala and parts of the North-East. Hinduism Stack Exchange is a question and answer site for followers of the Hindu religion and those interested in learning more about Hinduism. Hindus who do eat meat, often distinguish all other meat from beef. The word go stands both for cow and rays of the sun. slayers (of the animal). In the same sense, people are also attached to the cultural symbol. Is it a sin to eat meat in Hinduism? I don't have sources for these as there are word of mouth folk-lore. Such a one indeed would be likely to be born (again) as a strange being, (as one of whom there is) evil report, such as 'he has expelled an embryo from a woman,' 'he has committed a sin;' let him therefore not eat of the cow and the ox. Killing a cow mean you are destroying a chain of nature. Cattle generate methane a greenhouse gas . The milk of those cows as tremendous healing power including cancer. Growing up, I remember my grandfather taking me to the nearby gaushala to feed gau-mata on my birthday. Not like in the west or in the abrahamic faiths. He writes, In the old days, warriors of Kerala who were mostly from the Nair community, once trained in Kalaris, the schools of martial arts, took an oath to protect Brahmins and cows, as part of service to the king. In this verse phrase go-raksya was used, which means "cow protection". While the scriptures do not impose ban on beef consumption, it does not also endorse eating beef. @Mr_Green Sorry if I offended you, but my interest was not to debate my life choices. I had done survey on Cow slaughter and eating beef. Sraddha, their gratification, it is said, lasts for a full year. Did Hindu Brahmins eat beef? Vyacheslav Gladkov, the governor of Russia's Western Belgorod region, confirmed that the parents of a young girl, had tragically died in the incident. It's not fear but respect for this prescribed atonements that make many righteous people avoid beef consumption. In recent years, a major reason many diners have stopped eating beef (or are trying to reduce their consumption) is because beef production is known to contribute to climate change. heavenly bliss; let him therefore shun (the use of) meat. Why can we eat 'living' plants but not 'living' animals? It is definitely a great sin to kill innocents. Just because we know someone who is doing something that might be against the basic tenets of Hinduism, doesnt mean that the dogma has to be done away with. For instance, Sacrifice of horses is meant not for the purpose of enjoying its meat. Thus a cow is a symbol of the spiritual light within us. Answer (1 of 4): Yes, 1) some of them to become strong 2) Some of them to feel how it tastes 3) Ancient Hindus used to eat beef 4) Swami Vivekanand said: "You will be surprised to know that according to ancient Hindu rites and rituals, a man cannot be a good Hindu who does not eat beef". What do the Vedas say about animal sacrifice? Stack Exchange network consists of 182 Q&A communities including Stack Overflow, the largest, most trusted online community for developers to learn, share their knowledge, and build their careers. Killing a cow causes as much himsa and bad karma as killing any other animal. Does ETB trigger after legendary rule resolution? or has received it as a present from others. Which heads the list? That means Hinduism suggests that you should not eat beef, but it does not assign a punishment to violators. @Rickross Sri K.M.Ganguli translates the text as ray of sun. There is a lot of discussion underway regarding the permissibility of the consumption of beef in the Hindu religion. the cruel Brahmanas that gathered there for assisting at the What Are Hindus Not Allowed To Do - Hinduism Facts In general, meat has been mentioned several places in the ancient texts. I dont believe in that. Do hindus eat pork? Is it allowed or banned? : r/hinduism - Reddit There are many other instances. Is the practice of killing a cow for a guest ( | goghna) still followed? Vegetarian is best and something I'm working towards Vignaraja 2 yr. ago I don't, but I can't speak for all Hindus. History is proof most Hindus never had any beef with beef Holy or not? 3. The word that signifies the cow stands also for the rays of the Is it sinful to eat beef? You should not cut hair or nail on Saturdays. That animal nature will start manifesting itself. 2) No intoxication (alcohol, smoking, tea, coffee, etc.) Fact Check: The Wire peddles lies, claims Pune school Principal thrashed for conducting Dear Lord prayers, no CCTV in girls washroom, here is what Panchayat election was a fight for stature, Mamata Banerjee had to show that she is No.1: Rajdeep Sardesai downplays violence in West Bengal, Opindias prophecy comes true as French leftist media unleash anti-India propaganda, vitriol against PM Modi during his visit to Paris, Sound of Freedom: Read how the Leftist media lobby in the West is trying to dismiss and defame a movie on child sex trafficking, Nothing illegal in BBC presenter paying teen for his sexually explicit images: Young persons lawyer, Kedarnath temple committee bans the use of mobile phones, photography, and videography on temple premises; violators to face legal action, Mumbai: Aadhar cards with QR codes given to 20 stray dogs outside the Airport, The Battle Story of Somnath: Film on Islamist tyrant Mahmud Ghaznis invasion of Somnath Temple announced, Gujarat: Woman gets husband arrested 7 times in less than 10 years in Mehsana, then bails him out every time. They come up with these texts: It is not sinful to eat meat of eatable animals, for God has created Are you eating it because it tastes good? Yet, we see that there are more non-vegetarian Hindus than Vegetarian ones. We ate Misal Pav. While those who take the position that consuming beef is unacceptable and should be considered a taboo (and a non-negotiable) are considered orthodox, those who say that it is a culinary preference theorise that the former is trying to mirror Islamists and are attempting to ex-communicate people from the Hindu fold for eating beef. Many of these injunctions look outdated to us too because our lifestyle has been altered quite significantly. Meat eating though not recommended is allowed by many traditions, but Cow meat is forbidden and violations are punished. This could very well be true for several other sects that consume beef today. In the Bhagavatam cows and Brahmanas again stand out in the canto 10, chapter 24 "Worshiping Govardhana Hill" where Lord Krishna encourages his father to perform a sacrifice: SB 10.24.25: Therefore may a sacrifice for the pleasure of the cows, It is for only sacrificial occasions. I must not forget to mention, in passing, and as the opportunity arises, the great honour rendered by these people to cows, however low-bred, filthy, and all covered with dirt and dung they may be. body, is endowed with all the limbs, and is not crippled in any limb; Agni Puran 227.40 A king should sentence death to those who kill a cow. Manu says: 11.108. Killing of acow or murdering a Brahmin? Therefore, we can also see what is the method for atoning the sin of killing a cow. What punishment is given for it in hell? While I wondered whether I should even eat there or perhaps just stick to my coke, a friend proceeded to order a beef burger. Does that mean I have the authority to excommunicate someone from the faith? Site design / logo 2023 Stack Exchange Inc; user contributions licensed under CC BY-SA. cow shines like a second sun in resplendence. Is there an identity between the commutative identity and the constant identity? we have been exceedingly pained by it."'. Cow is not worshipped as per canonical scriptures, in some Godly sense. Just like saluting the indian flag, does not mean you are saluting that piece of cloth(of which flag is made). Hinduism and its complicated history with cows (and people who eat them) Are cows sacred to all Hindus? I have been told many a times that I shouldn't eat beef because I am a Hindu by religion. restrained sense addressed Nahusha, saying, " Thou hast, O King, slain So the question you should ask yourself is whether you are eating beef out of rigid necessity. There is a Jihad against the Hindu Civilization in Kashmir and Maoists and Communists and Evangelical Christians seek to destroy our civilization as well. Beef parties are specifically held to mock Hindus, cows are deliberately slaughtered on the road, Hindus are called cow-piss drinkers by Leftists and Islamists and beef, has become their rallying point against the Hindu faith. Another tribal Hindu society requires providing feast to the society (or the village) and also offering prayers to the society's deities or ancestors. painful groans of the kine in a cow-slaying sacrifice, and observing Is Eating Beef A Sin In Hinduism? - TimesMojo Atharvaveda 10:1:29. Well there are plenty of verses prohibiting slaughter of animals but you asked for cows especially so I focused on verses that mention cow slaughter specially. Among a cosmopolitan crowd with liberal values, it is easy to lose touch with our roots and sight of our identity. Forming thyself with joints in proper order, harm not the Cow, Aditi widely ruling! the Creator himself. By clicking Accept all cookies, you agree Stack Exchange can store cookies on your device and disclose information in accordance with our Cookie Policy. Vedic scriptures are against any type of animal slaughter not only cow. I didnt say the ceremony. slaughtered beast has hairs. Most Hindus avoid eating beef as a result. Added excerpt for the first link. Thou hast also slain a bull, which is declared to be like unto [45] The Easter bunny is not a holy animal in Christianity. Some pantheistic sect of hinduism may even worship cow too in obscure literal sense, just as they worship tree deity etc. Hence I regret my inability to present my views. He who has committed a minor offence by slaying a cow (or bull) shall drink during (the first) month (a decoction of) barley-grains; having shaved all his hair, and covering himself with the hide (of the slain cow), he must live in a cow-house . those who are to be eaten (for those special purposes). 0 0 Reply Share HARRY 3 years ago Is it a sin to eat beef in Hinduism? - EatMeat Even those with no spiritual or religious reasons for rejecting beef can find it problematic for a number of reasons. 'How according to scriptures should one repent for killing a cow or consuming beef?' Sovereignty has no value if the nation state finds no expression of it's nationhood. November 3, 2022 George Meat Knowledge In Hinduism, the cow is seen as a motherly, giving animal and is therefore treated with respect. Do not kill our cows, horses and people. Where the concern of eating beef really belongs is its . This is the doctrine of Hinduism. meritorious (conduct). roots and fruits, if given at Sraddhas, the Pitris, O king, remain versed in all the Vedas, and attain full longevity", should have rice her husband's house) in the Arjun (constellations).Srya's bridal procession which Savit despatched has advanced; the. 8. 11.109. We need to keep that in mind while trying to understand what he means. who serves it up, and he who eats it, (must all be considered as) the Judaism and Islam only have prohibitions against animals--they don't have holy animals. By clicking Accept all cookies, you agree Stack Exchange can store cookies on your device and disclose information in accordance with our Cookie Policy. What do Hinduism says about Cow / Gomatha3. There is no sin in eating meat, in (drinking) spirituous liquor, and in . Having grown up raising cows and watching how they show emotions, especially with my parents who were very fond of the cows, Sadhguru's words make a lot of sense to me. The previous and the next shlokas clearly mention about the Oxen driven chariots. Later scriptures condemn animal sacrifice. Question: Is Eating Beef A Sin In Hinduism? - all about vegetarians The myth I've heard is that it was done since cattle population was declining steeply and they needed some measure to stop it and hence adopted such a stance. Sadhguru is talking about the 'software' of human beings, not lions or other animals in general. I think you may not be knowing about Aghoris in hinduism, they are biggest follower of the LORD SHIVA. And the reasons cited for the taboo were entirely religious. In India, 81% limit meat in diet and 39% say they are vegetarian | Pew You can go through them- Part 1- Hinduism and Cow-. Not killing a cow simply means not doing any immoral act that dims that spiritual light. Vegetarianism Recommended in Vedic Scripture. It was a symbol of Hindu resistance and assertion that our faith will not be taken hostage by a secular state that is hell-bent on giving ancient tyrants far more respect than the people of the land. Last updated on July 2nd, 2021 at 11:35 am by Rahul. It is not venerated, worshipped, or held sacred. My argument here is rather simple it is entirely possible that the sect evolved into eating beef for reasons other than them considering it acceptable from the time of their ancestors. Cattle in religion and mythology - Wikipedia Required fields are marked *. - you mean for people who believe killing cow is a sin? Can the people who let their animals roam on the road be punished? However cows is explicitly forbidden to kill! Just as the swan or goose (hamsa) is a resonant symbol, the Easter bunny (representing a virgin birth) and the fish (representing Christ) are only metaphors. The other argument that is often furthered is that several Hindu communities do consume beef and hence, not consuming beef cannot be a litmus test of being Hindu. In 2020 a similar case came to light as well. All of this is known and is not challenged by anybody. Beef eating is considered to be great sin, cows have been an integral part of Hindu society, Ma Saraswati is seen as Kamdehnu, the cow who fulfills all desires, Mahadev's vahana is Nandi, a bull, Shri Krishna was a cowherd as well, in an agrarian society like Bharat, cows have always been a boon to the farmer and pastorist households, it is from. Even in Arya samaj sect, which only worships one God and does not worship idols and does not believe in Avataras; that sect also revers Cow, they also explicitly treat her as cultural symbol of Vedic Hinduism. Even sankhya followers, who are atheistic; they also give respect to cow and do not eat beef. The giver of a cow becomes the progenitor of a very large race It is one of the most misunderstood concept in Hinduism. What is difference between Shruti and Smriti? Well into college, even the discussion of beef consumption was not really something that was discussed, as it is today. I am confused regarding the five deadly sins mentioned in shastras. Saluting the flag means you are respecting the national symbol , which represents the nation and its ideal. both the eaters and the eatables. he who entirely abstains from meat, obtain the same reward for their entirely abstain from eating flesh. Yajurveda 30:18. Thou hast perpetrated an evil act, O Nahusha, and 11.108. To me personally, it appears to be disingenuous and I try to keep away from such pursuits. Other animals, like the fish (a symbol of Christ), are just symbols or metaphors. Is egg vegetarian in Hinduism? There is absolutely no way that anyone can be ex-communicated from the Hindu society, least of all, on the say-so of someone like me. Therefore, we can also see what is the method for atoning the sin of killing a cow. [Manu (Chandogya Upanishad 5.10.9). So when they altogether do not beleive in God, so there is no question of worshipping anybody. The eater who daily even devours those destined to be his food, commits no sin; for the creator himself created both the eaters and Stack Exchange network consists of 182 Q&A communities including Stack Overflow, the largest, most trusted online community for developers to learn, share their knowledge, and build their careers. The cow has always been the symbol of Hindu resistance towards imperialism. Absolutely. are called in the Srutis the Unslayable. Why Is the Cow Important to Hindus? - Beliefnet which persons conversant with the ritual of the Sraddha regard as That would imply that ancient Hindus used to eat meat. On festivals, I remember the first few rotis being made as a prasad to gau-mata. shatapAtha brahmaNa Kanda III, adhyaya 1, brahmana 2 prohibits bull/cow slaughter for beef with reasons: 21. Early humans used to be hunter-gatherers until they discovered agriculture. brhmanas and Govardhana Hill, and also to Me. But somewhere along the line, my opinions changed. But uniformly across all the sects, the common thread is something like below: Cow is actually given respect as cultural symbol. He who has committed a minor offence by slaying a cow (or bull) shall drink during (the first) month (a decoction of) Learn more about Stack Overflow the company, and our products. Almost every scripture prohibit the consumption of beef(cow meat). So, we can conclude that there is ZERO mention of cow meat eating in the ancient Hindu texts. Most people who grew up in a traditional Hindu family are well aware of the significance of the cow and the taboo against eating beef. According to Manusmriti above, it is not sinful to eat meat. If you go into detail, then horse sacrifice is done for a yajnya known as Aswamedha. Meat is usually eaten during the offerings and sacrifices which is still the case in the Hindu society. Is eating Beef a sin || Gomatha in Hinduism || Iam Praveen Kumar Can you please cite your reference? there are scientific logic and day to day thousands of benefits from cow. He who wishes," May a son be born to me, who will be required It is possible that Hindus initially used to interpret not killing a cow in a spiritual sense. I am, obviously, no Dharmaguru to make that assertion, so, of course, I am speaking in my personal capacity. Why are Hindus not allowed to eat beef when scriptures seem to indicate otherwise? We will add more information to this article from time to time. I have heard arguments that eating beef is not a sin in Hinduism. Heartfelt gratitude for the Essentiol Ethical Princioles od LifeOur wONDROUS aNCIENT sANATANA dHARMA*** nAMASTE hARE kRISHNApADMA, 4 Donts in Sanatana Dharma (Eternal) Meat Eating in Hinduism and Buddhism - Hindu Website Killing a cow is also not allowed as it is considered as one of the biggest sins. Repentance or atonement for killing a cow or eating beef When first time i was eating it I was feeling very upset from inside. Indra used to eat the meat of cow, calf, horse and buffalo. Meat-eating in India: Whose food, whose politics, and whose rights? Hindus are not allowed to eat beef because the cow is considered as the most sacred animal. Cow is considered as mother because we consume her milk lifetime and in Hindus family we worship them and even treat them as our family member. Unwasting Drop, red, eager, pressing forward, Agni I worship with repeated homage. Is it a sin to eat beef in Hinduism? - Sage-Advices (Astrological belief). worshipping them, he shall remain in the (posture, called) virasana. However, talking about personal non-negotiables is essential because it is out of those personal opinions that a societal opinion is crafted.